Just over a week ago I tweeted a picture of a setup I had going on my PC Desk; Essentially, fill a cheese grating tub with iced salt water (the salt lowers the freezing point of water, hence it’s use on icy roads), put the grating lid on top (leave the tub lid off, but you can use it to prevent spillage whilst moving the unit around) and place it in front of an old PC Fan you have lying around. You’re going to want as big a fan as possible, as they tend to have both respectable airflow and reasonable noise levels.
The way this worked was that there would be a chamber of air above the iced salt water that would be cooled when air particles hit the water and transferred their heat energy to the water – heat will always travel towards the cold – and the air will thus get colder. The fan will then pick up this chilly air and thrust it towards the user, while fresh air will be sucked into the tub to be cooled by the iced salt water and thrust forward.
It seemed to work, both in principle and in practice, but it did have some drawbacks:
- The cooling effect depends on whether or not the air remains in contact with the water long enough to lose a significant amount of heat energy, if it even contacts the water at all.
- The fan was never exactly stable, being unprotected and therefore prone to breakage (of either the fan or my fingers).
- As I have learned to my cost, the iced salt water solution is very easy to spill.
So this got me thinking: Was there a way for me to bypass the need to rely on air – a notoriously poor conductor of heat – in order to transmit the heat from the air to the iced water solution directly?
The CPU Cooler in question
It was at this point that I remembered about the Zalman CNPS9900 MAX that I had recently dispensed with from my Main PC on account of the space it took up inside the now tiny case. Zalman were famous for their flower-shaped CPU coolers in the Athlon XP/Pentium 4 days when I began in PC Hardware, and this design was their last hurrah, a circular rebuke to the quadrilateral, functional wave of the future that now dominates CPU Cooler design. Effective, yes, but also incomparably bland, as is now becoming true of most AIO Coolers.
This cooler has been in my possession since 2011 and has outlasted several generations of graphics cards, so I felt it was my duty to give such a long-serving component a new lease of life, even if it suffered the ignominy of being perched upon a lunchbox for the rest of it’s life.
The Component Parts
Still, a fantastic CPU Cooler is worth nothing without the right kit to enable it to perform it’s job. In a PC this means a CPU to perch it on, and in this case it means the following items:
Could hardly be simpler, could it? The only additional bits used were a couple of compounds; Nut Lock to set the nuts in place, and TIM (Thermal Interface Material) to create an effective heat transfer between the heatsink and CPU Cooler by filling surface imperfections with a conductive paste.
The build commences!
The whole process was over in a couple of hours. Not so good for aesthetics, but brilliant for those of us with things to do and places to be.
The End Result
I would say the results spoke for themselves, if this was indeed anything more than a proof-of-concept. This device looks like the sort of constructions that would scatter around weapons laboratories up and down the country in the next world war.
So how effective is it? First impressions indicate a positive result, with the air being blown from the device being noticeably colder than if it were from the CPU Cooler alone. How does it satisfy the three drawbacks I outlined before?
- The cooling effect no longer relies on the rather dubious concept of air being cooled by a chilly body of water in an enclosed space, and then extracted by a fan. The chilly body of water is now receiving heat energy from the CPU Cooler taking it from the air, transferring it to the lower heatsink, which then conducts it to the water. In doing this a direct heat path to the icy water is created.
- The fan is mounted into the CPU Cooler, which means it is protected by it’s fins. The Zalman doesn’t have an outer shroud like most CPU Coolers do, so the blade tips are still vulnerable, but it’s a better deal for both your fingers and the fan than simply standing it up on it’s frame. Most modern CPU Coolers use fans with an outer casing. There is also the fact that it is mounted to a lunchbox full of water, which prevents it from tipping easily.
- The gap for the CPU Cooler and heatsink to mate through isn’t watertight, so spillage is still possible. The aforementioned stability of the device and the fact that the edges of the lid are sealed, however, does mean that spills are a lot less likely.
So there are many concrete advantages to this configuration. With regards to it’s effectiveness, however, going by “feel” is no way to ascertain whether a device is functioning correctly. Join me next week as I obtain a thermometer and put this to the test, also assessing this solution against the old cheese grater solution.